Book Launch: “Tertutupnya Pemikiran Kaum Muslimin” Translation of: The Closing of Muslim Mind by Robert R Reilly
September 15, 2017

Date: Saturday, 23rd September 2017
Time: 2.00PM – 5.30PM
Venue: Spices, Concorde Hotel, Kuala Lumpur

Video Recording: Youtube LiberTV


Ever wonder why there are some Muslims, despite having good education and excellence grades, could be sympathizers to terrorist causes, could believe in superstitions and conspiracy theories, and could somehow be fatalistic and have double-thinking in their professional and in daily life? And why, sometimes, the educated Muslim could be hostile towards reason (akal), freedom, and free will?

In this book, the author argued that the real problem in the Muslim society, ranging from ignorance, unreality, extremism, totalitarianism, and intolerance, is not from their lack in economy, politics and power, but more from the level of intellectual and ideas. To tackle this, we must address the problem at its root cause, not just the surface only. The problem of Muslim mind, that produced the doctrine of Islamism and breed some sort of religious extremism and terrorism; is the underlying understanding of the reality which is hostile towards philosophy and rationality, a product of a long process of intellectual suicide that had happened years ago.

Here, Reilly investigated some fundamental issues on why Muslims, especially Sunni Islam, tend to dismiss rationality and seemed to live in unreality. The closing of the Muslim mind, as suggested from the book’s title, have more to do with the establishment of one particular theological school that calcified almost all prior schools into one coherent and dominant Sunni Islam thought – the Asha’irah.

Long ago, just two centuries after the death of Prophet Muhammad, Islam flourished as one of the great civilizations, a cultured society and kingdoms where science and philosophy blossomed and their thinkers became authoritative references to neighboring regions including Europe. But this success was short lived after the defeat of the People of Reason (the Mu’tazilites and philosophers) by the People of Traditions (the Asha’irites). The process of dehellenization initiated by the most prominent Muslim theologian, al-Asha’ari, and then coup de grâce by al-Ghazali had closed the door of philosophy and science on the Muslim land.

The battle between the Mu’tazilites and the Asha’irites, even after almost a century, was a decisive one. This battle established the principles of how Muslims should look into his religion, into his world, and even into his understanding of God; as a pure will with radical volunteerism and occasionalism; or as an established fatalistic doctrine of Islam aftermath. How reason was demoted, why the lack of creative and independent thinking, why modern concepts such as freedom, democracy, and rights are aliens to the Muslims of today; could all be traced back to the defeat of the People of Reason in that decisive battle centuries ago. Even the conspiracy theories that are widespread in Arab news channel, or the unreality world lived by Muslim fundamentalists or those extreme terrorists, could all be traced to this battle of the ideas that shaped the realities of the Muslim mind.

The closure of the Muslim mind has created the crisis of which modern Islamist terrorism is only one manifestation. The problem is much broader and deeper. It enfolds Islam’s loss of science and of the prospect of indigenously developing democratic constitutional government. It is the key to unlocking such puzzles as why the Arab world stands near the bottom of every measure of human development; why scientific inquiry is nearly moribund in the Islamic world; why Spain translates more books in a single year than the entire Arab world has in the past thousand years; why some people in Saudi Arabia still refuse to believe man has been to the moon; and why some Muslim media present natural disasters like Hurricane Katrina as God’s direct retribution.”

The Islamic Renaissance Front strongly believes that there is a dire need to rejuvenate the Muslim mind, to bring back the discourse of reason pioneered by our predecessors of the Mu’tazilites, and to bring this message to a wider audience in Malaysia. Thus, we decided to facilitate the dissemination by translating this book into the Malay language. We hope that this book will spark a debate and discussion, and hopefully it will create a more critical, inclusive and progressive understanding of Islam within the wider Malay-Muslim community.



1400 – 1430:  Registration

1430 – 1440:  Welcoming Speech by the Chairperson, Dr Ailin Razali

1440 – 1500: Opening Speech by Dato’ Redzuan Kushairi

1500 – 1530: Speech and Official Book Launch by Mustafa Akyol

1530 – 1550: Speech by Dato’ Dr Ahmad Farouk Musa

1550 – 1610: Speech by YB Saari Sungib

1610 – 1630: Speech by Dato’ Dr Mujahid Yusuf Rawa

1630 – 1730: Discussion and Q & A

1730:              Tea

Organized by:
Islamic Renaissance Front

Video Recording:

Contact Us
Islamic Renaissance Front
26th Floor Menara Maxis, Kuala Lumpur City Centre, 50088 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
Phone: +603-2615-7919
Fax: +603-2615-2699
Updated version: 2.39-20231022